The Bigger Picture: Visual Archives and the Smithsonian
A Photographer, Not a Terrorist
Starting last fall, stories started popping up in the British media and online about photographers who’d been stopped by officials empowered to question and search them if they seemed suspicious or might have some links to terrorism. Since then, more first person and news reports describe how tourists, journalists, and professional and amateur photographers alike have been questioned because they’d photographed subjects such as the Tower of London, the Royal Family, the interiors of railway stations, shopping malls, and buildings of architectural interest, or those that happened to be adjacent to office towers housing the offices of major banks or brokerage firms.
As instances these “stop and search” incidents began to mount (see a video made of an Italian art student’s arrest here) , a group called “I’m a Photographer, Not a Terrorist” formed to track the story as it has developed, question government policy, and make photographers aware of their rights. Click here to see their website, which includes information, images, videos, events listings, and photo-ready and stylish line of merchandise.
On January 23, an estimated 2,000 protesters gathered in Trafalgar Square in London, to demonstrate against legal restrictions on their right to make photographs in public places as defined in Section 44 of the UK’s Terrorism Act of 2000. Under that law, authorities have the power to stop and search photographers in both specified and unspecified areas in London and in other cities, and can view photographs in phones or cameras, but are not allowed to erase them. They can, however, seize equipment if they suspect its use may contribute to a terrorist act. As CNN reported, it was a lively event, including protesters who wore police costumes and badges identifying themselves as "vigilance officers," and people dressed as "freedom wardens" also made their way through the crowd pretending to arrest photographers.
All joking aside, while Europe’s Court of Human Rights quickly ruled against Britain’s “stop and search” practice as a breach of human rights, the British government has appealed the ruling, claiming that right stop-and-search is central to the fight against terrorism.
This story is not going away anytime soon, as a recently posted piece on London’s Times Online site reminded me. Controversy continues to swirl about what kinds of picture-taking and images should or should not be legal to take, given the threat of terrorism, issues of child protection, and privacy concerns.
Comments (1) – Leave a comment
I agree with people standing up for their rights, but they have to understand the government isn't doing this to violate their rights, but to protect them. When terrorists attack, people cry out why? why? And when police conduct random searches people cry out why? There has to be understanding and patience on both sides here.
Leave a comment
Produced by the Smithsonian Institution Archives. For copyright questions, please see the Terms of Use.
About
Smithsonian on Flickr Commons
Topics/Tags
- See Here (611)
- American History (542)
- Science (429)
- Archive (329)
- Cities/Places (277)
- Exhibitions (234)
- Web/Tech (210)
- Photo History (189)
- Link Love (153)
- Politics/Government (153)
Blog Roll
Categories
- Collections in Focus (989)
- What Gets Saved (337)
- Behind the Scenes (212)
- Smithsonian History (134)
Monthly Archive
- May 2013 (21)
- April 2013 (26)
- March 2013 (26)
- February 2013 (26)
- January 2013 (28)
- December 2012 (26)
- November 2012 (28)
- October 2012 (32)
- September 2012 (26)
- August 2012 (31)
- July 2012 (26)
- June 2012 (27)
- May 2012 (27)
- April 2012 (27)
- March 2012 (28)
- February 2012 (27)
- January 2012 (26)
- December 2011 (31)
- November 2011 (28)
- October 2011 (35)
- September 2011 (31)
- August 2011 (35)
- July 2011 (41)
- June 2011 (43)
- May 2011 (33)
- April 2011 (40)
- March 2011 (43)
- February 2011 (35)
- January 2011 (36)
- December 2010 (42)
- November 2010 (40)
- October 2010 (44)
- September 2010 (37)
- August 2010 (39)
- July 2010 (38)
- June 2010 (37)
- May 2010 (42)
- April 2010 (44)
- March 2010 (47)
- February 2010 (40)
- January 2010 (39)
- December 2009 (43)
- November 2009 (34)
- October 2009 (11)
- September 2009 (11)
- August 2009 (12)
- July 2009 (14)
- June 2009 (10)
- May 2009 (12)
- April 2009 (14)
- March 2009 (10)
- January 2009 (1)


